You're both right. Although atm there aren't the two guilds up that play as the core of the battlegroup. If there were then getting new guilds on different servers would be easier, still to have a new guild form whilst there already being 2 active guilds you'd need a decent group of players that know each other.
That's always been the problem though, waiting for those 1 or 2 players that wan't to create a guild that raises the bar, saying that, a few have already cropped up that look like they have the potential to do just this, so here's hoping.
Edit - Yeah forget about that, I missed the point Ishh was trying to make, having 4 small sets of guilds would be better than 2 big ones. I'm so fucking tired, 39 is a clear example of this, with 2 guilds, if 1 guild dies then the other does eventually, 29 at Cruelty is another decent example, they have a fair few guilds and thus have great activity, the only downside I see with multiple guilds is that WSG's become solo based and if my friends didn't play then I wouldn't, not to mention WSG no matter how many times you get it a day must get frustrating or very boring with complete PuG raids. So a mixed bag! But for now I wan't the 2 guilds to get rolling, and if a group of 5 friends decide to roll on a diff server, then good luck to them!
Anyway, be on Friday for some arenas and Sunday for WSG.