Lets not lose sight of the subjective nature of opinions. It's okay to disagree.
People aren't arguing the idea because their complete lack of rational argument to my proposal shows this. People are arguing in favor of not having PUGs as opposed to having 24.7 PUGs. Clearly flawed reasoning behind this argument...
People are arguing against my name because it's popular to do so more than my actual proposal.
I understand some people will disagree... but if my proposal is taken seriously, it would be a win / win for everybody. Our community would grow which will give us more numbers to make wargames happen and more guilds to premade against, we would have 24/7 PUGs that are going to pop very, very frequently AND they'll be more fun than the BH rofl stomp PUGs that we've had every few months for a few days for the past 3 years. Realistically speaking, if you can't be bothered to play with "jajas" you can easily get 9 more people to do wargames with. PUGs require coordination of 20 people syncing TWO queues at the same time... Wargames require 2 groups of 5 people ready to queue at the same time. There is no argument that getting wargames to happen is harder than getting PUGs to happen. The argument is that these wargames are not fun and will not be balanced. Newsflash, if you have any game comprised of twinks only, chances are 99% of the games are not going to be fun and are not going to be balanced.
Either way regardless of if my post will be taken seriously or not, it has created enough buzz hopefully for us to get pops tonight which is another means by which my intentions were merely for the greater good of the community. People need to wake up and take the content of what I do... Not the name by which it's posted just because some people that others look up to don't like me. It's clear that people would rather argue than to get pops to happen and to play their twinks. This is why I'm not nearly as passionate about 19s as I had been for the past 9 years.
I mean we've created so much exclusion in our limited pool of players. We've divided ourselves to the point where we can't even get PUGs to happen and none of these players is interested in recruiting.
Newsflash, we haven't recruited players since Cata... we've only lost them and given our trajectory, we've been on a decline until Blizzard made some changes with WoD and some people got into twinking on their own. PUGs that we get now maybe only have 4 names from TI in them per game. That is until the BH stomping crews hear that PUGs are happening and then from then on queues are dead within 3 games because we're tired of getting stomped into GYs by FOTM classes. We've been stomped into our GY with FOTM classes for the past 3 years. People need to have the guts to step down from playing with the intentions to destroy everybody in PUGs and save that gameplay for WARGAMES.
If you're truly a good player at your class, prove it by playing a spec that isn't ridiculously overpowering.
Just my 2c, I'm not going to discuss any responses to this post because I can say before they are made that they will only argue against my passionate posts because of my name and not of the content. It's a waste of time trying to push through to people who have killed their own queues. They'd much rather point their fingers at a yellow name than to accept responsibility when I told them years ago that we'll end up exactly where we are now if we didn't make a change. Forget the possibility that they would ever inspire to create change. I mean you're ddosing your own community so nobody can play and you're still being looked up to by most of the members. Clearly no community that I'm interested in devoting most of my time and effort into. Yet I'll still be on and queued twice for WSG.
(edit this post is not 100% in response to Conq)