I thought about making a post like this, except for the exact opposite reason.
It's weird, I agree things should be good. Scaling, no chants, everything should play very balanced. But it's not, it's horrid PvP, it just is. I'd rather have WoD back tbh and the 29 monks. At least a coordinated team could still beat that.
I think a big problem is the combination of xpon and xpoff. They really honestly have no idea what to do. They just sit at roads and fight. In WoD I at least knew I'd get a good match everytime. That people elected to stop at this bracket which generally came with some basic understanding of the games.
CC is pretty gutted. Some classes do OK still. Rogue is strong. Mage is just horrid, don't even get me started. There isn't a lot of point to CC. Most classes can just eat the 6 secs. The usual support classes do almost no damage so it's actually an overall lose to the team to role it. You'd be better off rolling a surv hunt and downing a healer then trying to get cute with a poly. I understand they have their moments but by in large damage > all.
Fine I'll do it, wtf frost mage, like seriously. You ruined this class. Every minute I do stupid damage and then nothing until it's off CD again. There's no control, no silence, no movement. Flurry is a waste of a GCD. I've played it for probably 5 years, daily through the 29 monks and hunts. I know it's never been FoTM but at least you could still impact games.
So yea, I'd take WoD over this. 0 ability to change your character,. Your naked counterpart has the exact same health as you and maybe 1% less stats. Not a lot of reason to work on your character and devote the time to it.