I don't want to participate in this thread (I don't want to judge or be judged), but, for those of us who would like to read the thread and maybe learn something, it would be helpful if you all would a) name the person you are critiquing, in case someone else posts in between you, and b) say SOMETHING about how you reached the conclusion, be it their gear, their reputation, their helpfulness/friendliness, their skill in battle and how you know it, anything.