Deviate Hatchling
Grimclaw
RoP
Martyr's Chain
Witching Stave
that skull-mace, forgot the name of it
lots of recipe:speed potions
took an Ally Protadin to Northern Barrens for the Giant Growth recipe, killed Herzul about 30 times til I gave up. Started leaving and some mob right on the border of the oasis dropped it. Not sure how rare that is.
mage farming chests for MM found instead: Brawler's Gloves, Diamond Hammer.
Doomspike
Some sword I'd neve heard of dropped from Pythas in TWC. I guess this is the rarest drop I've seen.
Thorbia's Gauntlets
Black Malice
Twisted Chanter's Staff
Keller's Girdle
Tree Bark Jacket
Peashooter (that's rare? seems like I see it often)
Yet MtB elude me endlessly.
Don't remember seeing: Drakewing, MM, SF, Gargoyle's Bite