actually, im pretty sure that pally with Crested Scepter - Item - World of Warcraft wins, ive only ever heard of one trial with it, the name alludes me but ive seen it in his armory.
shadowfang, and a mage took it.
haha classic, if its any consolation ive had assassins blade snatched from me on my rogue as well as two swiftness recipes on her as well. imho WoW's loot system is flawed and only rewards the lucky and ninjas, as well as breaking up guilds over rare drops in raids