If You Could Turn Only 1 Item Into Legendary Quality...

[Tom Ganks]

What item would it be? Hearthstone? Shadowfang? Barbaric loincloth?

 

[jwl]

https://www.wowhead.com/item=34247/apolyon-the-soul-render Comes to mind

 

[Crystalpall]

If you played F2P horde in cata, I'm sure you'd agree the skillpatch should be legendary

 

[Chops]

If you played F2P horde in cata, I'm sure you'd agree the skillpatch should be legendary

Then horde would just have whined more

From a lore perspective, I always felt that Gorehowl should have been a legendary and I feel like blizzard did ol' Hellscream dirty by making his axe, the axe that slew Mannoroth, a random ass drop off a no name boss in a pre-raid. They didn't even make it the arms artifact in legion.

Bullshit.

 

[Sin'dor]

What item would it be? Hearthstone? Shadowfang? Barbaric loincloth?

Obviously the Lucking Fishing Hat, of course!

[...] I feel like blizzard did ol' Hellscream dirty by making his axe, the axe that slew Mammoth, a random ass drop off a no name boss in a pre-raid.

Truth.

 

[ohti]

duh

 

[Blackberryy]

https://www.wowhead.com/item=34247/apolyon-the-soul-render Comes to mind

I actually have to agree with this, tbc was cool with adding both a melee and ranged legendary, and maybe legion ruined my pure tbc bloodline but a new caster legendary and a str dps legendary would have been really cool for tbc.
And I don’t mean the TK legendarys

 

[Kaxle]

Then horde would just have whined more

Damn straight. Had my cow ass runnin around in bunny ears

 

[Speratic]

Dreadnaught T3 Set, but if it cant be a set, T3 Dreadnaught helmet

 

[Neon]

I am fine with the legendary items in classic and do not want any changes made outside of the phases.

 

[jwl]

I actually have to agree with this, tbc was cool with adding both a melee and ranged legendary, and maybe legion ruined my pure tbc bloodline but a new caster legendary and a str dps legendary would have been really cool for tbc.
And I don’t mean the TK legendarys

I remember my first *serious twink*
It was a level 70 blood elf paladin. It took me over 60 weeks for me to get my soul-render and after months of building up anticipation, it truly felt legendary when it finally dropped.

This weapon specifically shouldn’t have been a brutal gladiators recolor, it 100% deserved to be one of a kind