Consumables in a Premade

Should consumables be allowed in organised premades facing each other?

  • Yes, all consumables should be allowed.

    Votes: 23 32.4%
  • Yes, but certain limitations should be put in place, decided between the two teams.

    Votes: 21 29.6%
  • Yes, but only Rumsey Rum, Healing Potions, Mana Potions and other standard level 15 food.

    Votes: 20 28.2%
  • No, consumables should not be allowed at all.

    Votes: 7 9.9%

  • Total voters
    71
hey crit you member Jumpy? well i'm back and wanting to twink again. I'll try to find u on the server my guy is leader of the old HI Vangaurd lol. Guess someone gave him lead and left it to start the new HI

Awesome! We are all back in HI. I will shoot you mumble info. :D

Sent from my DROID RAZR Maxx using Tapatalk 2
 
Last edited by a moderator:
hear theres a group of 19's in white gear who do wargames.that might be more your speed.

You and Myaahh should find a 3rd person and we could have a fun 3v3 deletion series against my buds and I
 
it's about certain consumables (FaP and minor resist) becoming part of every players rotation because people start abusing them.

Actually I totally share your concern about potion abuse. My rogue, Capias, developed a real potion abuse problem, and ended up having to go into guild-run detox unit at a spa just outside of Silvermoon.
 
I agree that this feud between families has gone on long enough, and has strayed the focus of this thread for quite some time.
Lets move back to the topic at hand, consumables, their affect in premades, and reasons as to why or why not they should be limited!
Edit: Ty Broken
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I voted for the option in the poll 2nd from the bottom, because other consumables are unfair/imbalanced in the sense that they interfere with certain classes more than others (limiting class diversity and making it more boring)
 
Last edited:
I agree that this feud between families has gone on long enough, and has strayed the focus of this thread for quite some time.
Lets move back to the topic at hand, consumables, their affect in premades, and reasons as to why or why not they should be limited!

For any of this discussion to matter you have to do premades in the first place. 5v5 is not a premade and favors the Alliance heavily anyway.

kratos, how many 10v10s have you done in this bracket and how many do you have scheduled?



Sent from my DROID RAZR Maxx using Tapatalk 2
 
Sorry but to be fair simply complaining about consumables instead of playing around the POSSIBILITY of them being there is a little weak.
That'd be like "No dark flight that ruins melee chance of keeping up with you sans snares. " or "no concussive shot because it counters dark flight".

Quoted for truth and simplicity.

Sent from my DROID RAZR Maxx using Tapatalk 2
 
For any of this discussion to matter you have to do premades in the first place. 5v5 is not a premade and favors the Alliance heavily anyway.

kratos, how many 10v10s have you done in this bracket and how many do you have scheduled?



Sent from my DROID RAZR Maxx using Tapatalk 2

We have one this Friday against some randys, you might have heard of them they go by <Horde Invasion>
 
Quoted for truth and simplicity.

Sent from my DROID RAZR Maxx using Tapatalk 2

Please. Let us not forget that you lost a game for your team by speed potting away from your healers. Seems to be comsumables aren't all that good if you ask me.
 
To be honest, This thread could of just been kratos's OP about why we dont use certain stuff, and it could of ended there.
 
I think consumables in any form are fine only if both sides agree upon them before hand. In PuGs it doesn't matter.
 
We're trying to hold our premades to the higher standard of RBGs, not just BGs. Blizz's view on wether or not consumables should be allowed in a RBG are quite clear.

By that logic lets all get our manual crowd pummeler for only the classes that can wield 2H maces and get that 500haste buff, I mean it has a CD, should be allowed right?

Now believe it or not Critster, you do not dictate what the 20-24 bracket is. These are the rules I'm implicating for my guild, if you don't want to play us, don't. I'm sure we'll survive, we've dealt with enough of your 5-6 mans to know we won't be missing much.

And small cesspool? Look around you, Honeybadger, Agonist, the entire laughing skull guild of 24s, almost all of <CC>, and many of your own HI players hail from 19 bracket; we're not going anywhere. Numbers mean nothing to me Crit, in my books quality will always conquer quantity, and you can que with your 6-7mans and have them all on all the time, but when they face a group of well coordinated and geared players, they will break like twigs.

24s will keep getting better, I have no doubt. With more competition coming in from the 19s and other brackets once they hear there are premade ready guilds on both sides, I can guarantee you the quality of players will only rise.

We wish the best of luck to HI and their future premades, I'm sure Sanctuary will be very accommodating. :)

I could be mistaken, but as far as RBGs go. Maybe, just maybe. The reason behind those not allowing consumables is because people are lazy?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top