Dorigon
Alpha and Omega
MoP babies...
19 Twink Hall of Fame
- Thread starter 19 Twink Hall of Fame
- Start date
- Status
MoP babies...
Rap Game Holylipz
Legend
You're in luck, I usually don't do this kinda thing.
19 Twink Hall of Fame
Legend
When I say 75% vote, I mean by the actual committee, not people who have posted in the thread. There is a group of very qualifed 19 twinks who all had a say in who should be in the Hall of Fame. The committee went through a voting process on each member as well as players who were suggested in the thread. Ondura did not meet the 75% vote requirement. This is a US thread as you can see by the prefix. However, exceptional players like Vianco and Stubs, for example made a big enough impact during the time they played on the US servers.
Pizza is already listed for Druid.
Since requested, explanations for each member will be added soon.
Rap Game Holylipz
Legend
Hell yes! Shout out to Noodle Arms.
Junoo
<XL>
i wont mention that half of what i posted was ignored but lets progress. who selected this "committee" and how can we be sure to take there word as fact?
Mocha
Legendary
Junoo
<XL>
im quite confused to why you think im "jealous" of such a thread. im merely poking holes in logic im let to be believe as fact. its human nature to question whats being told as fact.
Dorigon
Alpha and Omega
im quite confused to why you think im "jealous" of such a thread. im merely poking holes in logic im let to be believe as fact. its human nature to question whats being told as fact.
What is so difficult for you to understand? Certain people, especially those who have barely played in US, have understandably not passed the committee's selection process. 'Facts' have nothing to do with it. Do they not have halls of fame in Europe? Did you have to conduct research in your Encyclopedia Britannica to find out what one even is?
Junoo
<XL>
i understood what was said fully, you fail to see my logic hunny.
Baked
Retired Aussie
i like you but shhhhh please
i dont want another GOOD THREAD derailed
|
edit: i like dory's idea
Last edited by a moderator:
19 Twink Hall of Fame
Legend
Good idea. I have decided to move Pizza and Vianco to the last category for obvious reasons.
As promised, explanations for each player will be edited in eventually.
Look, it doesn't really matter what Ondura did on EU, this thread is about US. The committee does not care if there is a player on EU that is better than everyone in US, if they haven't made a significant impact on US servers, then they don't belong in the 19 Twink Hall of Fame for US twinks, as you can see by the prefix. Certain players have made a big enough impact to be inducted, like Vianco, Stubs, Nicozy, and Arkant.
You are implying that because he is in TL, which you state as the top guild on US, he deserves an automatic ticket into the 19 Twink Hall of Fame. I'm sorry but that's not how it works. It was actually a unanimous vote that Ondura shouldn't be in the 19 Twink Hall of Fame, mainly for US players. In no way does it mean he isn't good, it's just that during his short time on US servers, he did not make a big enough impact. There are players on this list with over 100k HKs. Arudno has 5.2k HKs.
TL is a strong guild don't get me wrong, but I don't know if it's right to state they are the highest rated guild on US, unless you are referring to highest rated guild in pugs, but that doesn't mean that much. The only premade they've had on US servers as a guild was against a Real ID team and that was only one game. Premades will not happen for a while, but it would have been nice to see them play RT, AtW, and EbK.
im quite confused to why you think im "jealous" of such a thread. im merely poking holes in logic im let to be believe as fact. its human nature to question whats being told as fact.
Your logic is that because someone is in TL, a strong guild, they deserve to be in the 19 Twink Hall of Fame.
Feel free to make your own 19 Twink Hall of Fame for EU and post the entire TL guild roster. Hell, you could even call it TL Hall of Fame. I'm sure that would get Cogbrew wet.
Also, if anyone is concerned about the low representation for monks, the reason is two-fold. First, there just aren't that many monks in the bracket. Second, possible candidates that could potentially fit in this category like Curley, Ko, and Slyddur have too much history as rogues. It wouldn't feel right to put Curley in the monk or miscellaneous section, for example.
Also, if you haven't noticed, colorful in-game/forum personalities does play a factor.
Camo
Grandfathered
I don't know if its just me but when I think of hall of a fame caliber player, the best of the best comes to mind. People shouldn't be added to the list because they were pretty good.A lot of the players mentioned are/have been pretty good, but I wouldn't consider them to be hall of fame players or icons of the bracket. I considered myself to be a pretty good frost mage, but I definitely wouldn't have considered myself a hall of fame player especially due to my lack of premade experience or my overall positive impact on the bracket outside of my guild. It's also not fair to leave out older iconic players that were famed for their play in vanilla, bc, or wrath. But yea anyway, I probably took this thread too seriously lmao.
Quack
Guest
IMO us is controlled by raw talent, people believe if they call you good or bad, at the end of the day who cares ? Because you pay for this game to have fun .
.- Status