Most iconic/influential/unique twinking items over the years

[Sanit]

 

[Tweakedirl]

Jar of Spiders

 

[Bestworld]

Jar of Spiders

Oneshotting lvl 100's on my 19 with that shit never got old.

Iconic: Lucky Fishing Hat, Shadowfang, Talbar Mantle, Sentry Cloak, Arena Grand Master, Inferno Robe

Influential (to what extent?): Enti's Quenched Sword, cata satchels, MoP cloak enchants, Felforged, Common Legion Blade, Brewfest Steins, items from BFA rares.

Unique: TCG items (tabards, flag of ownerships etc.), Precious Ribbon, Haunted Memento, Formal Dangui and other random items.

 

[Cattywompus]

Classic. Lololol

 

[Kirise]

MAGIC DUST

or otherwise known as twink crack

I still have some of that stowed away on a 29 (alongside my Crescent of Forlorn Spirits).

Formal Dangui

This, right here. Some items augmented the impact for a class or playstyle (PoD, spellshocks, marbled buckler, crescent of forlorn spirits, Razzerik's), and some transcended class and playstyle to become a staple of the bracket (LFH, AGM, green lenses, Rocket boots for 59s). But a select few, like the Formal Dangui, were responsible for making certain twinks worth building in the first place.

 

[Outofspace]

The Blades come to mind: Wingblade, Zealot Blade, Runic Darkblade. Other random weapons floating around my brain: Torturing Poker, Twisted Enchanter's Staff, Windstorm Hammer, Corpsemaker, Taskmaster Axe, Lil' Timmy's Pea Shooter, The Butcher.

There was a 2H hammer all the 29 palis used that I can't remember, and it's really bugging me!

 

[necroaqua]

Having the TCG turtle mount way back before the heirloom mount. I still have defias gloves/boots with mount speed enchants in the bank.

Also flurry axe for 49s.

 

[Tweakedirl]

Elemental Force
Crusader

Still suprises me that most nontwinks dont realise you can enchant Heirlooms on a high level toon and mail them to a level 1