To my surprise I have seen more skilled warriors shit on hunters, mostly cause all hunters players are trash, the few and far between good warriors can give them a run for their money. Some hunters are mechanically skill some just smash buttons. Yet I have seen top warriors reck face occasionally, not often, but sometimes.
When Executes a proccin, don't come a knockin, Warrs are a prob for hunts 1 v 1, issue is in BG when you are chasing one down, being kited by mages, locks, other hunts, etc.
Still, I have killed 5 toons in like 10 seconds with Execute and Death Sentence PvP talent.
Other times, it doesn't proc for like 2 mins, and it's a strugge as Arms.
This is just one style of play that is very hit or miss.
Fury has better survivability but Arms is my choice on warr for PvP hands down.
Mages are a hard counter to hunts too, should be able to beat Marks and BM,
Survival is harder to kite and win against.
Ret Paladin should beat hunter 1 v 1, Survival again, being the exception imo, at this 20's bracket atleast.
Frost and maybe Unholy DK as well imho.
Gear and enchants, matter.
I see a ton of heavy metal, pallys, warrs, Dk's with no Crusader enchants on weapon(s) in BG's.
Even, ... or especially if you're leveling this makes all content easier and PvP a better experience for the player
as both damage and survivability are boosted.
And, like on my WW Monk and Feral, which are great fun to play, if other faction is running a bunch of hunts....
I log and get on my hunter as well because no amount of gear and/or skill is going to help when other team has 6 hunts that run around the map together taking peeps out.
Elite players on any class can beat an average pugger 1 v 1 anyday.
Skill, knowledge of other classes CD's, etc. makes a difference.
BG's are generally won by which team has the better heals. (that actually are healing team and not just themselves)
Duels and Arena's are different.
Correction: when I stated mages can beat hunts, in this bracket, I meant, Arcane specifically.
Fire and Frost are pretty weak, in 20's bracket.
Later on, as other classes get more skills and talents, it's all different.
Haven't been in touch with endgame PvP at all for years since Lich King days.
Used to be tons of endgame PvPers out front of SW or Ogri dueling for hours on end.
Don't see this very much anymore.
You could get a pretty decent idea of endgame class 1 v 1.
Frost mages, Aff locks, and Ret Pallys were hard to beat back then.
Also, Survival hunter was a ranged spec in those days,
with Explosive shot & all the traps. In the right hands was hard to beat as well.