If I did have to make a list: anyone with an above 70% win ratio should do. If I did have to make a list tho:
I'm not sure how a ratio matters however
Winning more makes you, in the long run, a better player... (given you don't AFK)
this I agree with completely. Winning does make you better and I can say being 100% sure that 1k bgs ago I wasnt nearly as good as I am now and every 5/10 bgs I learn something new. Nothing is more important then experience but let me just say this as an example.
Bison has a 62% wsg ratio
I have a 60% ratio
TK (sry bison and bend but arguably the best druid in this bracket) has a 60% win ratio
agu (arguably the best horde pally in this bracket) has a 58% win ratio
The thing with all of these people? They pug in atleast 90% of their bgs
No disrespect to any of these people but these are some people who have a very high ratio and just simply wouldn't if they pugged 90% of the time
cer (great FC but simply premades all to often) 77%
felix (we all know felix's premades) 83%
cherrypi (presonally never saw this hunt that I can remember but has been said she organized 10 person premades) 81%
This is simply taken from the first 50ish people that I recognized on lofi's list (lofi also pugs like 99% of the time with a 59% win ratio) and this shows without a doubt that win ratio doesn't matter when you pug. Premades should have better win ratio and premades should have more skill theoretically but imo after seeing this bracket for over a year alot of puggers have more vast more skill then most premades and that is why I chose to make my list on mostly puggers cause you can tell skill from a pugger alot easier then you can by someone in a 5 person premade with people always around to help them.