Spiritual and Light were the first feared paladins I came across. Maybe it was because of the grudge match we had, but that's really what it should take to be considered one of the best. If you aren't feared, you aren't remembered. Some of the names listed (outside Light) really don't strike familiarity. In addition, Drinker should be placed on that list. He plays many characters, but his Paladin is a train. It's tough to top any "best" list when you switch between characters too often. It takes a lot of time time, and a lot of consistent battlegrounds to master one class. The best of the best cannot be the jack of all trades.
Duopaladin should be mentioned, but he plays Horde, and I can't fear him
Drinker is also 29, but w/e