EU+US Hand of justice trinket never procs

[Sockdolager]

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/item/11815

^^ after a month of using the level 48 version of this all the time I haven't seen any indication that it actually procs - no animation and no text in the default UI combat log, no animation, no sound. The wowhead entry (https://www.wowhead.com/item=11815/hand-of-justice) seems to indicate it should be displaying a "hand of justice" entry in the combat log. I've tested against combat dummies and against mobs and BG players. Can someone give me a sanity check and screen shot of theirs proccing?

 

[Samadius]

it simply is another melee attack entry. It has 2% proc rate. If you use MSBT (Mik's Scrolling Battle Text) addon, you will quite often see a 'Hand of justice' icon when it procs. Also hear a little sound and animation same as when ironfoe, flurry axe etc. procs if I am not mistaken. It does work and using it combined with chance on proc weapons can be good.

 

[Dimefox_]

It might be good for chance-on-hit effects, i don't really know. But as a warrior, in prot, I will say that its awful for a dps boost. Skada shows it as ~1% of damage done.

Sent from my TA-1025 using Tapatalk

 

[Sockdolager]

it simply is another melee attack entry. It has 2% proc rate. If you use MSBT (Mik's Scrolling Battle Text) addon, you will quite often see a 'Hand of justice' icon when it procs. Also hear a little sound and animation same as when ironfoe, flurry axe etc. procs if I am not mistaken. It does work and using it combined with chance on proc weapons can be good.

doesn't scrolling combat text just parse the default combat logs for all of it's data? If so -- there is nothing in mine distinguishing its proc from a normal white hit.

Ironfoe procs as expected and has the thrash blade effect in the default combat log -- hand of justice has nothing. Perhaps it is an issue with the current, scaled version? It just dropped for me since the patch -- perhaps previous versions are working correctly -- mine shows zero indication of working at all.

anyone able to log into their toon and either test the old or new version and post results of what they see here?

 

[tomxoqt]

Try the 12mainstat/twelve versa one from Dire Maul. Or the haste one. Both are good and will add more damage to your character overall.

 

[Blackberryy]

i have the original unscaled version from before any of the newer patches. And I also have yet to see an indication of its proc even monitoring auras and checking mutiple combat logs

 

[Ikaar]

So I wan enhancement for a while. Was rocking iron foe with hand of justice. And well i do think youre right. We did alot of testing with this in our guild because I wasnt the only enhance. I have yet to see that proc ever, ive done test with guildies for a while now and like said above. Everything that had an extra attack shows up as trash blade. Even iron foe, now the trinket literally nothing happens and it has been like that for a little bit. I swapped to resto and now can 2v1-3v1 the right people and not worry about procs that dont work! The 12 agility only with a proc that never works is not worth it at all. Only thing worth noting is blizz did a damage reduction this last pack for oncomming damages I believe i saw?
[doublepost=1539178096,1539177731][/doublepost]

So I wan enhancement for a while. Was rocking iron foe with hand of justice. And well i do think youre right. We did alot of testing with this in our guild because I wasnt the only enhance. I have yet to see that proc ever, ive done test with guildies for a while now and like said above. Everything that had an extra attack shows up as trash blade. Even iron foe, now the trinket literally nothing happens and it has been like that for a little bit. I swapped to resto and now can 2v1-3v1 the right people and not worry about procs that dont work! The 12 agility only with a proc that never works is not worth it at all. Only thing worth noting is blizz did a damage reduction this last pack for oncomming damages I believe i saw?

 

[Alîce :-)]

I use HoJ trinket often enough when I play retri, I can tell you it does proc, but doesn't seem to do an animation for the extra attack. But I can say for sure it does proc! Hope this helps!

 

[Blackberryy]

I use HoJ trinket often enough when I play retri, I can tell you it does proc, but doesn't seem to do an animation for the extra attack. But I can say for sure it does proc! Hope this helps!

Can you prove it does? Because I’ve tested this for days on end and not had it proc once

 

[Alîce :-)]

I use the MSBT addon that Samadius mentioned earlier, it will alert you on a HoJ proc. I could see that without this addon it would hard to know if it is proccing or not as it has no animation! Hope this saves you from anymore testing!

 

[Tzvetan]

@Blackberryy are you testing it on a 70?

 

[Ikaar]

Ive never. And i mean never got it to procc once on my 49 before swapping to resto, it was a good 3/4 weeks. It dropped first run same with iron foe i was super excited and it was dogshit.

 

[Sprite]

It does proc, like mentioned before, if you use MSBT it alerts you when the proc occurs.

 

[Blackberryy]

Yes @Tzvetan

 

[poppabear]

It does proc, like mentioned before, if you use MSBT it alerts you when the proc occurs.

this.....literally did this last week.

also, when ironfoe procs, you see a buff where you only speak in dwarvish. forgot what its called, something forge. I went over to the dummies in kultiras and tested using details and never saw the proc, I then googled addons to track "extra attack" and Mik's scrolling battle text or msbt can be configured to notify. The default setup didnt for me, but under "triggers", add new trigger, extra attacks. you can specify a sound or whatever and it will show both ironfoe and hoj procs. ironfoe procs a LOT, but i wasnt impressed with hoj procs. It was nice to finally see it being tracked though.

 

[Samadius]

yeah hand of justice always had a 2% proc chance (I read it somewhere in old vanilla posts), and it diminish above lvl60+ afaik. I remember hearing that sound similar to flurry axe procs too when it procs. Been a while since I paid much attention and used it though. But yeah most combat logs and dmg meters don't show it. But I believe it still works.

 

[Tzvetan]

Yeah, there's a lot of indication that the proc rate drops off considerably at 61+, to the point where it's probably not worth using.

 

[kkaabb]

if some more testing is needed ppl could use weakauras addon with trigger for spell https://www.wowhead.com/spell=15600/hand-of-justice

 

[Samadius]

yes this is one more proof
[doublepost=1540739117,1540738932][/doublepost]if you still never see it you probably don't have it enabled in your combat log settings. To do that go to your combat log > right click > settings and this window shows up. Make sure the "Extra attacks" is ticked.

 

[Stale]

I think HoJ can also proc off Windfury or Ironfoe attacks.

So the joke would be to have Ironfoe, Flurry Axe and HoJ and a Chance on Hit enchant as enhancement shaman.