Cake V.S. Pie - Ultimate Debate

Cake V.S. Pie

  • Cake, Clearly

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Pie Dude!

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Neither

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Both (Cheater)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other - What?

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
So which one shall win? Go!



http://img10.imageshack.us/my.php?image=pietfu.jpg
pietfu.th.jpg
 
Well, I'm at a loss- is Cheesecake a pie or cake? Its in a pan, round, and every pie like, yet is does have "cake" in the name...



CHEESECAKE WINS by default!
 
well then i officially vote to rename cheesecake to cheesepie.



still...banana cream pie > cheesepie > all other pies > cake
 
the thing about pie is that it can be a whole meal



a small pie to start, then a larger savoury pie for main and a nice pie to finish



can your cake do this? no.
 
pie sucks, cake is good if it's chocolate.



cake > pie, but for the most part, twix > all.
 
oh druid you just commited cardinal sin #1 claiming a candy bar is > all.



ok, new proposition of how the heirarchy goes:



banana cream pie > cheesepie > all other pies > vanilla cake > cake > chocolate cake > candy bars.



whew...ok wow i realize i've posted waaaaay too many times on this subject...perhaps this is a statement to my culinary prowess when it comes to desserts =P
 
Naturaltalnt said:
you forgot the first part of your chain Druid, Crunch > Twix > Snickers > Goodbar > Hersheys.
crunch is good if you want a very eatable candy bar. but it does not taste as good.



also, 100 grand would make my list of top 5.
 
Cake is limited to JUST being a dessert. Pie is not limited to this as we can clearly see in chicken pot pie, crawfish pie, sheperds pie, minced meat pie, etc..

Pie is a treasure chest of open imigination and delight, while cake is only to complement something else and is a palette for icing or a place holder for candles. If pie would be served at a wedding it would be served at or during the wedding and not after. Cake comes second then, and second now.

The only way you can select cake is that you can never get it off your mind and you may wish to up your dental plan and buy some bigger pants. The only other way you can select cake is that you prefer things that are limited, just sit there, and come in second to everything else, which means by selecting cake you are selecting pie as number one and we thank you.
 
Tusktuki said:
Pie > Cake Always duh. Anyone who says different is a commie



communism would work as long as everybody was ok with working an equal amount of time/effort as everybody else in a society where nobody got anywhere



CAKE



edit



erm, i forgot about chocolate cream pie :< wtb re-vote
 
Naturaltalnt said:
BTW Druid, where you the one that hit the "other" choice, in favor of candy?

no, actually i hit cake.



maybe i should have hit 'other' though.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top