Lets see. Names with reasons for some included, and reasons for not inclusions for others. Also, may I remind you this is the OLD SCHOOL PvP list (I'm taking this to be classic/BC). That means that if the player was garbage back in the day, you aren't supposed to include them in this list (even if they are "good" now). Lets be real, 19s now have such a low skill cap across the board that you can be good at every spec if you're just good at one. Back in the day multiclassing was a big deal in all brackets (including end game). Now it just makes you the average decent player. As an addendum, I don't play 19s anymore so I don't care or know how good these people are now.
Priest:
BCBeaux - He was good period. (You can add Whinke if you want as well, but he was just a Beaux clone).
ClassicKidneypopper - Also good.
ClassicDismay - She was pretty good, though not at the same level as others.
ClassicKancer - Say what you want, Kancer did his thing with the original MP.
ClassicFony - Fony, was.. well Fony.
ClassicSeepsmash - Giant dick, but very good. (Add him to rogue as well)
BCBladesmaster
BCQuara - Very good but definitely theorycrafted WAY too much. Also his full spirit set idea was full on retarded.
BCPym - Decent, had problems with not getting kicked though.
I want to put that priest Mirage because he was a beast but I don't remember if he was good in BC.
Warlock:
BCScourge (Hiredhit) - He was easily the best lock there's ever been in this bracket. I've never seen better and he got Gladiator the same season he decided to FIRST try end game on his lock.
ClassicDrayner - He was very good, prolific at making twinks and the people that hated him just hated him because he was largely untrollable. He would frequently make fake alts and get invited to big guilds on skill alone.
BCMaineack - Good PH lock.
ClassicFair - Great lock.
BCCptnjack - Probably second only to Hiredhit
Mage:
ClassicCloudkill - Obviously one of the best mages, only played in 'clone
ClassicDeathsstone - It's Dstone, he's always good at everything (Put him on Rogue/Mage/Priest/Hunter as well)
ClassicIcyjr - No idea how people forget Icy. He was literally the first mage twink. Everybody just copied what he did and he made mages into a necessary premade class; whereas, before him no one had one. Can't tell you the shock on our faces the first time we all sat in slows for an entire premade, we had no idea what to do.
BCCtrlaltsheep - RIP Sheep. Great mage.
ClassicSnapifex - MYT's main priest. Not including Nas cuz he was pretty bad to be honest.
ClassicSumma - Summa was good on all the healer classes but mainly priest in my opinion.
ClassicSnowboots - Oldest mage twink for sure, but one of the best
BCFirefleas - No Mercy's All Star D pretty much boiled down to him on mage.
ClassicResisted - AYGAT's finest.
ClassicBebetta can get an honorable mention. She was okay, but she was definitely better than 99% of the mages out there at the time so I'll give her the benefit of the doubt.
ClassicGerms
ClassicProvacature
Druid:
BCGaaz - one of the best FC's and he led NM
ClassicRecovery - first FC druid ever.
ClassicMoonwalks - He did his thing. I forgot the name of the rogue he played with that was really good too. They were best friends or something. Babywhisp-something?
ClassicFc - Carried that Crushridge Legend D like a boss!
BCZerged
BCDazzlerazzle
ClassicBigclancy - Beast (Fc)
ClassicMfspam - Amazing druid
ClassicBragh - Like most of AYGAT/ DYFL, he was very good.
BCFroby
Rogue:
ClassicMythos - One of three rogues that were amazing in classic. He had a bad habit of either being on or off.
ClassicBlackout -Monster rogue
BCHiredhit
ClassicPwntage - Pwntage was good, period.
ClassicObliviate - Did things with a rogue no one else did for a long time.
ClassicCirran - Also very good with rogue.
ClassicLifedrain - The only thing he did badly was his reasoning behind playing with Heysus (who was god awful).
ClassicOneshot
ClassicDiablo
ClassicPyrathos
ClassicSpamcakes
ClassicShadowlurk
BCZero - That random rogue from Shattered Hand (I think? Or it might have been Argent Dawn). He was easily the best rogue at the tail end of BC given he beat everyone except that one 18 rogue in series).
BCGoma - Was deadly in WSG, was pretty good in arena.
BCSlyddur - Great 'clone Rogue
BCSalt - Pepper was never that good, Salt was.
BCBoderek - The first real, legit, actually good 10 twink. Hit hard as hell, was amazing at never showing his back. He was a 19 in a guild that I don't remember anymore (which is sad because it was a pretty big 19 guild but my memory for WoW stuff from that long ago is slowly fading).
ClassicVirreh - (I believe he is now a F2P twink with Atchyphobia)
ClassicShaitaan - One of Europe's finest.
ClassicOvation - AYGAT's finest. That Mage/Rogue video was one of the best old videos.
ClassicArdy - Sexy dwarf rogue. The one and only. (Ardee too)
ClassicVinknee - The rogue from Mostly Harmless. He was very good even though he was in an okay-at-best guild (even though I guess they were the best on Ruin for a while)
ClassicLethal - I feel bad because I want to put Sleyin because I liked him a lot but.. he just was not that good.
ClassicBeastly - He was... beastly?
ClassicKidneypopper
Shaman:
ClassicVelricc - He was just good at shaman like no one else was.
BCIgne - Also good at shaman.
BCDirtyauction
ClassicWatchaa
BCFarmthis
BCBone, as much as Painaid carried the hell out of his teams, Bone was one of the few who did work.
BCAntility - As previously mentioned, he cared way too much about tennis. He was the only good boomkin though.
BCKunz - Pretty dirty at 24 mage too.
BCBobgnarly I'd go so far to say he was the second best BC shaman.
Hunter:
BCTipdrill - The hunter that played with Velricc. Destroyed everyone and he may have been better than Atax.
ClassicAtax - It's Merciless Gladiator Atax. Did things with a hunter and amazed everyone on PTR's because we all though hunters were utter garbage. Turns out they weren't.
ClassicPlaque - Average hunter who suddenly got a lot better. I remember thinking he was terrible and all of a sudden a month later he was one of the good hunters.
ClassicEverstride- BEAST of a hunter.
ClassicSasattack- Sorry, I'm not including Pizza because he was garbage in both classic and BC. I understand that he has gotten a lot better (and Congratulations on that), but given what this thread is meant to be, I have no idea why he is on any of the lists. I don't think he would even put himself on these lists if he was being unbiased.
BCRuin - Very, very good.
BCUnstablle - He was ridiculously nice, like the opposite of Seep nice, and he was pretty good to boot.
BCVonfonzy- People always forget he was good because of his ridiculous voice, but there it is.
ClassicNystricks - Did his thing. I have not seen a Nerf This member since BC though.
Warrior:
ClassicGorex - One of the few good warriors from Classic
BCBronzebeard
BCRick
ClassicSillus
BCSelm - There just were not a lot of warriors. Why would you play one when you could be a rogue?
BCBobgnarly - Nuts.
Paladin:
BCMerryjr - He was basically Painaid on a paladin in BC. Nearly impossible to kill.
BCPat- Great paladin
ClassicMmowned
BCDirtyauction
BCHbotz
ClassicAnarcan
ClassicTompopperr - Yay for at least one old paladin.
ClassicPerfection - This guy sucked to kill
BCZaxie
On a sad note. Pwndepot officially no longer exists so we can't even look over some of those very old threads. Also Desh, you were carried in every guild you were in. Everyone knows this. Why are you acting like you are good?
