Best all around Melee?

[Song]

Warriors are poop. I also feel that feral Druid burst and dmg is underestimated i have a feral and normally beat enh shammys, only downfall to feral is that you have no interrupts. unless tauren.

 

[DubbsBegins]

warriors arent the best at all indeed without healers.. but its so much fun with healers
arguably the most funnest class with healer

 

[Imirak]

At least against ferals, warriors are terrible 1v1. I basically play with them like a cat with a mouse when they actually try to fight me 1v1.

Why are ret pallies or rogues not considered here?

 

[DubbsBegins]

prot warriors can come really close tho against ferals. I sometimes lose to them if they get lucky crits so its not too terrible but still not the greatest
probably will win 80% of the time against prot warriors

 

[Mialo]

Are you sure throwing weapons do more damage then warrior throw? I remember a warrior doing like 600 damage with that in the vengeance times.

That would have been a very lucky crit then. I don't recall getting that high (maybe as a Prot?). Point is the CD isn't dropping fast enough to get the Rogue down before you die yourself.

 

[Exalt]

Thanks for all the replys everyone. You really helped me out. Because I think I'm going to role all 3 classes plus a pally lol

 

[Exalt]

can a ret pally put out more damage then a warrior?

 

[Mialo]

can a ret pally put out more damage then a warrior?

I would say yes. Since you need a much higher skillcap in comparison to do the same with a warrior.

 

[TwinkO]

Warrior lose to shaman and druid in duels. Feral vs enc is like feral vs ret, with right rotation timing or tauren racial can win. In bg with heals warrior pwn all, because of powershifting and stealth feral pwn more then enc.
So I'd say duels - enc>feral>fury and other way round in bg - fury>feral>enc .

 

[Exalt]

thanks again guys. im going to do some experimenting