BiS shield for a Holy Paladin? (Human, no faction change)

[Magicuser]

Hi, just a query, I'm currently rolling a Holy Paladin and was wondering what shield to go with. On old threads and stuff as well as with the armory links there's been a lot of conflicting stuff.

Obviously Shield of Talrendis Point is the best, but as I want to play Ally and don't have the IRL cash to pay for a faction change I have a choice:

Forest Buckler - 2 stamina 4 intellect
Forest Buckler - Item - World of Warcraft

or

Seedcloud Buckler - 5 intellect 3 spirit
Seedcloud Buckler - Item - World of Warcraft

Is the extra intellect worth it? I'm kinda leaning towards the Forest, but still I'm unsure. Also I'm loathe to equip it until I decide, it being BoE.

Thanks!

 

[Junoo]

personal pref tbh, stat difference if minimal nothing game chaning

 

[lokah]

Seed cloud, more intellect and spirit is not in demand for holy paladins, but imo a little is nice to have.

 

[Hurrtink]

id roll with forest buckler 2 stam > 1 int imo ;]

 

[Mocha]

Alternate between Forest and Seedcloud!

 

[dartofblue]

Both shields are good, I'd only use seedloud if I also used serpentis' gloves & minthrust/crysaline

I roll with forest buckler

 

[Junoo]

Both shields are good, I'd only use seedloud if I also used serpentis' gloves & minthrust/crysaline

I roll with forest buckler

blahh cloth paladins make me sick.

 

[Nakedplumber]

Seedcloud has 17 more armor

 

[Magicuser]

Thanks for all the help!

I went with the Forest Buckler, I can always get Seedcloud if I change my mind and the enchant for it is in no way expensive