[The Great] Rogue Off Hand Weapon Debate!

[Duckhunt]

Please choose your top three Rogue off hand weapons and put them in order of greatest to least greatest.



(Shadow Fang and Assassin's Blade excluded)



Options:

[item]Battleworn Thrash Blade[/item]

[item]Butcher's Slicer[/item]

[item]Buzz Saw[/item]

[item]Buzzer Blade[/item]

[item]Cruel Barb[/item]

[item]Scout's Blade[/item]

[item]Skeletal Club[/item]

[item]Stinging Viper[/item]

[item]Tail Spike[/item]

[item]Thief's Blade[/item]

[item]Wingblade[/item]

 

[Duckhunt]

Please choose your top three Rogue off hand weapons and put them in order of greatest to least greatest.



(Shadow Fang and Assassin's Blade excluded)



Options:

[item]Battleworn Thrash Blade[/item]

[item]Butcher's Slicer[/item]

[item]Buzz Saw[/item]

[item]Buzzer Blade[/item]

[item]Cruel Barb[/item]

[item]Scout's Blade[/item]

[item]Skeletal Club[/item]

[item]Stinging Viper[/item]

[item]Tail Spike[/item]

[item]Thief's Blade[/item]

[item]Wingblade[/item]

[item]Battleworn Thrash Blade[/item]

[item]Cruel Barb[/item]

[item]Butcher's Slicer[/item]

 

[Fìalotta]

i whoude say

[Thief's Blade]

[Scout's Blade]

[Battleworn Thrash Blade]

 

[Tidal]

[ITEM]Wingblade[/ITEM]

[ITEM]Cruel Barb[/ITEM]

[ITEM]Thief's Blade[/ITEM]

[ITEM]

[/ITEM]

 

[Xposure]

Assassin's Blade (maybe it's not the best, but I like it )

Thief's Blade

Wingblade

 

[Doffe]

Cruel Barb

Wingblade

Thief's Blade

 

[Duckhunt]

This is not great unless more people vote! I'm looking for dataz here.

 

[Finks]

Battle Worn Thrash Blade

Cruel Barb

Thief's Blade

 

[Rayu]

Tbh with AB and SF not included in the list how are the results ever going to be fair?



I vote;



Shadowfang

Cruel Barb

Battle Worn Trash Blade



(I'm alliance and cba looking into horde gear it will only make me sad)

 

[Distort]

[Battleworn Thrash Blade] - proc chance for MH extra hit rocks

[Cruel Barb] - hard hitting OH especially if specced for OH dmg increase

[Thief's Blade] - fast hitting sword that has nice stats and more dmg because of

miss chance on OH.

 

[Xposure]

lol, just notice you said "SF and AB excluded" and not included in that case:



Wingblade

Thief's Blade

Cruel Barb

 

[Mummified]

hes looking for 3rd best off hand weapon behind shadowfang/assasin's.



imo wingblade. by far. thief's doesn't even compare to the dmg or speed.

 

[Kusakari]

thiefs by far



although i can't get wingblade so i haven't tested it.



however 2 sf with 5/5 duel wield specialisation would be pretty awesome

 

[Omgimarogue]

[Wingblade]



[Battleworn Thrash Blade]



[Scout's Blade]







it depends on whether you want a fast OH for casters, or slow for big burst



^ my 3 imo - in order

 

[iaccidentallytwink]

Thief's Blade is horrible.



[ITEM]Shadowfang[/ITEM]

[ITEM]Wingblade[/ITEM]

[ITEM]Cruel Barb[/ITEM]



Wingblade has 2 more stamina and 1.3 more DPS, there's no way that's worse than 2 Agi.

 

[Maerduk]

Lol whoa whoa whoa, wait, what's going on here, I actually see people voting for wingblade? Now how is this possible since it was such a "horrible" OH weapon... Anyway:



Wingblade

Battleworn Thrashblade

Cruel Barb

 

[Cookíes]

Cruel Barb (Fiery)

Thief's Blade (+15 Agi)

Butcher's Slicer (Fiery)

 

[iaccidentallytwink]

Butcher's Slicer (Fiery)

lol.



Thief's Blade is just bad. Why do people still use it?



[ITEM]Cruel Barb[/ITEM] vs [ITEM]Wingblade[/ITEM]

Wingblade is faster, more hits.

7 AP vs 2 Stamina and .2 DPS. Normally, 2 AP = 1 Stamina, so in this case 3 AP vs .2 DPS. Overall, I'd say Wingblade wins.

 

[Ramune]

whatever has the best DPS.

speed doesn't matter at 19 for offhand.

 

[Ogsir]

Why hasn't anyone said anything about any daggers?

I know its different but i have Tail Spike(+15 agil) OH

and for main hand Cruel Barb(+15 agil)MH

IF your a rogue you will anyways be kited by a hunter so why worry about stamina. Go for strict burst damage... glass cannon!.