i used to f2p on AP, and loved yasueh's mods. but, after a certain amount of AP drama, i realized that a couple people were ruining the experience for me, so i rolled new toons elsewhere.
i pug BGs from other servers and can tell you about my perspective. while i normally look at everyone's health, i look specifically at the gear on AP toons. most players pugging from random realms have 1000+ health with a mix of blues and greens. AP toons are either rockstars or the absolute worst. when you get AP toons with less than 500 health, dressed in whites, with thousands of HKs, they tend to make the entire realm look bad. people dont remember the AP toon who went 12/3 with a carry and a recovery when there was another AP toon who went 2/40, wearing whites and rushing mid.
while there might be room for individual recognition in BGs, AP has a reputation for erratic behavior. the admins at this site can tell you that the forum gets thousands of reads from unregistered guests every week. there are alot of random f2p players who read here without posting or rolling on AP. when they are getting gy farmed, the only thing they will remember is that there was an AP toon with top kills. they won't realize that it is just one asshat who wants looms on his 3rd toon. instead they will think that all AP players are twinkinfo hypocrites. when they see a bad AP bot, they start looking more critically at other AP toons. even decent bots are obvious when you watch with suspicion. then they assume that all AP players are twinkinfo bot cheaters. if the team is 3/4 bads and there is 1 bot, the loss will be blamed on the bot if they are from AP.
in every other pvp bracket, the best players are recognized by their guilds, without guilds in f2p, there is no way to enforce a set of behaviors that are important to the community. there is no way to recognize the players with a shared set of standards. instead, AP's realm success is attracting jerkoffs who are looking for the easiest routes to roflstomping.
cotus feels he has something to prove. kahr thinks that his $15/month makes him special. graveyard farming and botting are like cancer. they are ruthless and efficient. because the community hasn't found a way to stop them, the bad behavior spreads. when randoms engage in these activities, they hurt the community. when players from AP pull this crap, they hurt the community and make TI look like a joke.