19 Rogue offhands?

[死神様]

I'm stuck between Gutterblade and Heartseeker, which would be better? (Fiery)

This assumes that shadowfang is mh.

Any other weapon suggestions?

 

[Locked]

Theses two would be awful

Get CB or SF

 

[Shazzrah]

Heartseeker would be a valid option if it hit caps you.

 

[Locked]

Fiery would never proc and stats are better on sf/cb

 

[死神様]

what's cb?

 

[Twinkytoes]

Cruel Barb .

 

[死神様]

cruel barb offhand?? what now?

 

[Twinkytoes]

It's proven to be the second best offhand. Mathematically of course!

 

[死神様]

Where is this proof?

 

[死神様]

Oh and, why would fiery never proc?

 

[Twinkytoes]

Where is this proof?

This proof comes from no other than IAT. Most people do indeed hate him but he is fucking amazing at math, so no one will doubt him there.

 

[Omgimarogue]

if you have an SF mh, then go WB if you;re horde, or CB if youre alliance

and i have dual LS, get quadruple procs sometimes, so offhand procs indeed do proc, and give better burst than agi

 

[死神様]

Where is the page where I can find this information. ?

 

[McBankington]

I'm using SF/Butcher's slicer, not the best choice but I'm not a perfectionist and it's working well with 15 agi slapped on it. If you are a perfectionist go for cruel barb or Assassins Blade.

 

[死神様]

Why though? I can't find this guy's page so I can't see the math.

 

[死神様]

Wow, I'm stupid. Found 'im.

 

[死神様]

I see the spreadsheet, but I just don't see how a slower offhand is better dps.

 

[TwinkorDie]

I see the spreadsheet, but I just don't see how a slower offhand is better dps.

the whole premis that a slow offhand is better is dependant on you time on target. since 90% of the time your jousting or chasing and only have a few seconds to attack your target the slower offhand will yield higher damage. now if rogues had crip in this bracket, thiefs blade is hands down the best offhand. but we dont so its not.

 

[Murk]

I switch between [item]Cruel Barb[/item],

[item]Thief's Blade[/item], [item]Balanced Heartseeker[/item], [item]Gutterblade[/item]. I cant find one to use most.

 

[Pezin]

Rogues do not have poisons at 19.

Therefore, slower weapons are actually better because they do more damage on each hit. (more burst) They are also better because slower weapons proc 'PPM' enchants more times than faster weapons do.