Pure F2P can only get this if they are in a group with a vet or subbed player with the https://www.wowhead.com/item=88566/krastinovs-bag-of-horrors toy. Which I assume is a Heroic-only rare spawn. Guide here - https://www.wowhead.com/news/how-to-enter-old-scholomance-farm-once-removed-transmog-items-333981
dragpz it is heroic only for the toy. conzil I also looted it in the first room, actually got 4 on my first run.
@tokosa Yea I know, just saying theoretically impossible for Solo F2P because Heroic is locked at level 35 or something. But you can easily group with someone who has toy to unlock Old Scholo