Tattered Dreadmist Robe vs Robes of Koegler?

[Flaxy]

Tattered Dreadmist Robe vs Robes of Koegler

At 29 Here's the Stats for each :

Tattered Dreadmist Robe :
10 Armor
+9 Intellect
+13 Stamina
+9 Crit

Robes of Koegler :
9 Armor
+8 Intellect
+13 Stam
+5 Crit
+6 Haste


So Which Should a Disc Priest Use? is the +6 haste worth the -4crit, -1int and -1armor if I use the Robes of Koegler?

 

[Raz]

go with koegler imo it will scale to the same int/armor as the heirloom, ofc idk what ur going for haste or crit.

 

[Donteventrii]

Worth noting is you can put +5 stam kit on BOA only

 

[Zeiren]

BoA for Disc and Koegler for Shadow

I don't think that robe scales right?

 

[Sebs]

scales to 9 int

 

[Raz]

im pretty sure that the 5 stam kit could be replaced with Enchant Chest - Superior Stamina ?


Edit: may be wrong

 

[Zeiren]

im pretty sure that the 5 stam kit could be replaced with Enchant Chest - Superior Stamina ?


Edit: may be wrong

you are correct

 

[Sebs]

im pretty sure that the 5 stam kit could be replaced with Enchant Chest - Superior Stamina ?


Edit: may be wrong

Yes it does give 5+ i just checked in-game
to OP, if you want haste go for koegler, if you want crit go for dreadmist

 

[Donteventrii]

I guess the superior stam chant changed since wod drop? I remember discussing this with you around then [MENTION=710]Zeiren1[/MENTION]

 

[Zeiren]

I guess the superior stam chant changed since wod drop? I remember discussing this with you around then Zeiren1

I remember this conversation.

I just logged on my Monk and tested both. Borean Armor Kit gives +3 Stamina now and Superior Stamina to chest give +5.

Needless to say, If I was going to be using the Koegler's robe (for shadow spec), I would use Peerless stats anyways.

 

[Donteventrii]

Peerless is 2 all?

 

[Zeiren]

Peerless is 2 all?

yes

 

[Flaxy]

So what's the answer, boys?

 

[Sebs]

depends on your preference

 

[Flaxy]

depends on your preference

What're my choices between the two robes?

 

[Sebs]

What're my choices between the two robes?

If you want more haste go for sm robe, if you want crit for for BoA. About enchants, you want stam or 2 stats

 

[Flaxy]

If you want more haste go for sm robe, if you want crit for for BoA. About enchants, you want stam or 2 stats

Alright, thank ya qt.

 

[Original]

I think that SH robes w/ stam are the best for most, but obviously you can change things around if you want more damage or crit, but I believeSH robees are better in almost every way

 

[willix]

Tattered Dreadmist Robe vs Robes of Koegler

At 29 Here's the Stats for each :

Tattered Dreadmist Robe :
10 Armor
+9 Intellect
+13 Stamina
+9 Crit

Robes of Koegler :
9 Armor
+8 Intellect
+13 Stam
+5 Crit
+6 Haste


So Which Should a Disc Priest Use? is the +6 haste worth the -4crit, -1int and -1armor if I use the Robes of Koegler?

Considering that crit heals for Disc turn the crit amount into a bubble, I would think that Crit is more valuable for a Disc priest than Haste.