Prized Beastmaster's Mantle vs Champion Herod's Shoulder

[Xenophon]

Hi,

I have a F2P Worgy Hunter and I'm not 100% sure how to compare Prized Beastmaster's Mantle (PBM) with Champion Herod's Shoulder (CHS), especially when it comes to PvP resilience. Both items appear better than the Shadowfang Spaulders I have now but I wonder if the 1.75% PvP resilience (at L24) on PBM is worth sacrificing the 1.39% crit on CHS.

The Agi/stam is also slightly different. With my current gear, my HP scales to just under 2k, but an extra 2 stam has to be good in a BG, right?

The armor scaling isn't right, any idea what the actual armor value is? Is it updated when equipped?

Details from WoWHead @ L24:

Prized Beastmaster's Mantle
Item Level 1
Binds to Battle.net account
Shoulder
Leather

161 Armor
+7 Agility
+7 Stamina
+5 PvP Resilience (1.75% @ L24)

Champion Herod's Shoulder
Item Level 1
Binds to Battle.net account
Shoulder
Leather

161 Armor
+6 Agility
+9 Stamina
+6 Critical Strike (1.39% @ L24)

 

[Junoo]

no. pve shoulders.

no debate.

 

[crazedgamer111]

PvP resilience isn't as good as it should be right now, you definitely want that crit.

 

[Xenophon]

Thanks for the replies. You have confirmed my suspicions.